Back
In the world of synagogue management, there's a common misconception that financial performance should be evaluated solely on profitability, much like in the for-profit sector. However, this approach overlooks the unique nature and mission of synagogues as non-profit organizations. Let's explore a more nuanced and effective way to evaluate synagogue performance.
The Non-Profit Difference
Synagogues, like all non-profit organizations (NFPs), are not motivated by profits. While financial stability is crucial, the success of a synagogue isn't measured by its profit margin. Instead, synagogues are driven by their mission to serve the community, provide spiritual guidance, and uphold Jewish traditions.
The Power of Budgets
In the non-profit world, budgets are more than just financial planning tools – they're a reflection of an organization's goals and priorities. For synagogues, the budget process is an opportunity to align financial resources with community needs and organizational objectives.
For example, a synagogue might set goals such as:
- Supporting a membership of 350 families
- Educating 75 students in the religious school
- Running a preschool for 60 children
The budget is then crafted to achieve these goals, balancing expected revenues with the necessary expenses to provide these services.
Success Redefined
In this context, success is not about maximizing profits, but about achieving these community-focused goals within the established budget parameters. It's about effective stewardship of resources to fulfill the synagogue's mission.
The Importance of Inclusive Budgeting
To make this approach work, it's crucial to involve key stakeholders in the budgeting process. For instance, the preschool director should be part of setting tuition rates, determining staffing needs, and establishing enrollment goals. This collaborative approach:
- Ensures buy-in from those responsible for implementation
- Establishes accountability
- Increases the likelihood of creating realistic, achievable budgets
- Improves efficiency by ensuring those responsible understand how to properly allocate expenses
Aligning Accounting with Budgeting
For this performance evaluation method to work effectively, a synagogue's accounting system should align with its budgeting approach. This is where the concept of modified cash accounting comes into play – a method that Kesef strongly recommends for synagogues.
Modified cash accounting allows for a more straightforward comparison of actual performance against the budget. It avoids the complexities and potential distortions that can arise from accrual-based accounting in a synagogue context.
The Benefits of This Approach
By focusing on mission-aligned goals and budget adherence rather than pure profitability, synagogues can:
- Make more informed decisions about resource allocation
- Better communicate their financial status to diverse stakeholders
- Maintain focus on their core mission and community impact
- Avoid the pitfalls of short-term thinking that can arise from a profit-focused approach
Conclusion
Rethinking performance evaluation in synagogues requires a shift in mindset from traditional business metrics to a more holistic, mission-focused approach. By aligning budgets with community goals, involving key stakeholders in the process, and using appropriate accounting methods, synagogues can create a more meaningful and effective framework for evaluating their performance.
At Kesef, we specialize in helping synagogues implement these best practices in financial management. Our team understands the unique needs of religious institutions and can provide the tools and expertise needed to align your financial practices with your mission.
Ready to transform how you evaluate your synagogue's performance? Contact Kesef today to learn more about our tailored financial management solutions for synagogues.
