Back
Synagogues have few tasks as crucial - or challenging – as membership renewal. It's a process that often leaves staff and volunteers feeling constantly asked, reminded, and sometimes pleading. Fatigue is real, and it's felt on both sides of the conversation.
The Renewal Rollercoaster
"It feels like we're always asking," synagogue administrators say. Some feel like they send emails, make calls, and still, every year, they're chasing renewals right up to the High Holy Days. It's exhausting, and sometimes, it seems like they're more focused on forms and fees than on building the precious community.
This sentiment resonates across synagogues of all sizes. The constant cycle of renewal can be draining, not just for those asking, but also for members who may feel bombarded by reminders.
The Challenge of digital overload
In our digital age, the go-to solution has often been emailing campaigns. However, as some staff point out, "The email campaigns aren't working anyways. We already have several core members who have renewed. There are still people that think they auto-renew and don't have to fill out the form."
Especially in today's synagogue landscape, where it's just as likely you belong to a synagogue with a voluntary commitment model, as the traditional annual membership fee model, this insight reveals a crucial gap between intention and impact. While emails might seem efficient, they often get lost in daily life, especially amid the flood of messages filling our inboxes.
Rethinking Our Approach
So, how do we break this cycle? How do we make renewal less of a chore and more of a meaningful reconnection? Here are some thoughts.
- Personal Touch in a Digital World: You'll need to start calling those folks - it's the only way it can happen. While time-consuming, personal calls can cut through digital noise and remind members of their vital place in the community.
- Reframe the Conversation: Instead of focusing solely on the transactional aspect of renewal, use these touchpoints as opportunities to reconnect. Ask members about their experiences, needs, and hopes for the coming year.
- Spread Responsibility: Engage board members and committed volunteers in the renewal process. This not only lightens the load on staff but also reinforces the idea that membership is about community, not just administration. TOP TIP: Elul is coming up, it's the perfect time for the annual "Shanah Tovah" phone campaign!
- Celebrate Renewals: Make renewal a positive experience. Consider hosting a special event for early renewals or sending personal thank-you notes. Recognition can be a long way in encouraging prompt renewals in the future.
- Offer Flexibility: While almost all synagogues offer financial relief - the approach and delicacy of that conversation is paramount to allowing donors who donate less money to feel equally as a stakeholder in the community. In an organization where volunteer leadership is important, this is the only way to maintain that pipeline.
The Bigger Picture
Remember, renewal is about more than balancing the books. Many synagogues share a version of the following renewal message (you’re welcome to use it as well, we want to help!):
When you renew your membership, you're not just making a financial transaction—you're renewing your place in our sacred community. Your commitment breathes life into our shared spiritual home, nurturing a vibrant tapestry of Jewish experiences.
It's in the melody of prayers that lifts our spirits together.
It's the laughter of children discovering their heritage in our classrooms.
It's the warmth of a community that rallies around you in times of need.
It's in the joyous celebrations we celebrate life's precious moments.
It's in the quiet strength we find in each other during challenging times.
Your membership is a thread in our community, connecting the past, present, and future. It's an investment in a place where you can find meaning, grow spiritually, and be part of something greater than yourself. Here, we celebrate our joys, find comfort in our sorrows, and walk together on our Jewish journey.
By renewing, you're saying "I belong here. This is my community, my tradition, my home."
Moving Forward with Compassion
As we navigate another renewal season, let's approach the task with renewed energy and perspective. Yes, it's challenging. Yes, it can feel relentless. But each renewal is a recommitment to something greater than us – a thriving, supportive Jewish community.
For those of us at ShulCloud who work with synagogues daily, we understand these challenges intimately. Our tools are designed not just to track renewals, but to help you build and maintain the relationships at the heart of your community. We're here to support you in creating a renewal process that feels less like a chore and more like a homecoming.
Consider hiring our professional services team to curate one of our membership renewal forms for exclusive use in your congregation.
As you continue this year's renewal journey, remember behind every form, every call, every email is the opportunity to strengthen the bonds of your community. It's not just about renewing membership; it's about renewing connections, commitments, and the shared vision of a vibrant Jewish future.
Also, the ShulCloud Fundraising Module does an excellent job tracking all of your membership renewals, and membership renewal income.
Ask us how, today!
Ready to take your synagogue's membership renewal to the next level? Contact us today to learn how ShulCloud can tailor your communication strategies for maximum impact.
